Transcribe
Translate
Sunspots, v. 6, issue 6, whole no. 26, Fall 1945
Page 12
More information
digital collection
archival collection guide
transcription tips
Fall, 1945 SUN SPOTS Page 19 * * * * * * * * * * COMPOSITE LETTER ON LAST ISSUE (With remarks gleaned from reader's letters) EDITORIAL: interesting; interesting; very good; reminds me of my own career; interesting; liked it; best in issue; was informative. NOT ONLY NOVELS: good; not one short story in a hundred can stack up with the novels; obvious and mediocre; disagree; not up to Joke's usual form; agree with Joke; good; too much always said of novels; entertaining; good, but not connected; fair; lacked Joke's usual drive; left you hanging in mid-air. FANTASY'S THIRD FORM: interesting; article is going to get cut into a thousand pieces; interesting, but I question the admission of music to the field as fantasy's third form; obvious and mediocre; fine; good, but your forgot Revel's "Bolero"; was O.K.; you ruined it in your third paragraph by lowering your writing ability in the eyes of your readers. BEOWULF POLL RESULTS: interesting; good; interesting and surprising, accepted fact; interesting; why not repoll the top 15 or 20 fans again; was the article I spent the most time on; more accurate than the first poll; glad to see Finlay and Bok at top; informative; liked it the best; thanks for the review. ANOTHER CASULTY: is it really fiction?; amateurish and simple minded; was not fiction, rather a philosophy; slightly blind; "?????"; different from other styles; splendid, needs saying over and over; good thought, too short. LA TOMBE: fair, better than most stuff you see these days; amateurish and simple-minded; good; okay; very good, but I didn't get it; stinks; very well written. THE TRASH BASKET: good; very good news page; definitely not trash; interesting; interesting and informative; hot-bed of thoughts and information; very interesting; original, newsy, and mature. BACK COVER: Nice pic; quite good, Splawn has makings of good artist; it scared me; sensational! Sincerely, E. E. Evans, Steve Hanrahan, Richard Sneary, David D. McGirr, Beak Taylor, Richard Alnutt, Harry Warner, jr., Larry Bassett, Langley Searles, R.J. Gaulin, Frank J. Davis, Gus Dallas, Ken Kruger, Walter A. Coslet, Monroe Kuttner, Dale Tarr, Lionel Inman, Norman Wegemer, Samuel D. Russell, Francis T. Laney, and Charles McNutt. . . . Thanks for writing; please come again.
Saving...
prev
next
Fall, 1945 SUN SPOTS Page 19 * * * * * * * * * * COMPOSITE LETTER ON LAST ISSUE (With remarks gleaned from reader's letters) EDITORIAL: interesting; interesting; very good; reminds me of my own career; interesting; liked it; best in issue; was informative. NOT ONLY NOVELS: good; not one short story in a hundred can stack up with the novels; obvious and mediocre; disagree; not up to Joke's usual form; agree with Joke; good; too much always said of novels; entertaining; good, but not connected; fair; lacked Joke's usual drive; left you hanging in mid-air. FANTASY'S THIRD FORM: interesting; article is going to get cut into a thousand pieces; interesting, but I question the admission of music to the field as fantasy's third form; obvious and mediocre; fine; good, but your forgot Revel's "Bolero"; was O.K.; you ruined it in your third paragraph by lowering your writing ability in the eyes of your readers. BEOWULF POLL RESULTS: interesting; good; interesting and surprising, accepted fact; interesting; why not repoll the top 15 or 20 fans again; was the article I spent the most time on; more accurate than the first poll; glad to see Finlay and Bok at top; informative; liked it the best; thanks for the review. ANOTHER CASULTY: is it really fiction?; amateurish and simple minded; was not fiction, rather a philosophy; slightly blind; "?????"; different from other styles; splendid, needs saying over and over; good thought, too short. LA TOMBE: fair, better than most stuff you see these days; amateurish and simple-minded; good; okay; very good, but I didn't get it; stinks; very well written. THE TRASH BASKET: good; very good news page; definitely not trash; interesting; interesting and informative; hot-bed of thoughts and information; very interesting; original, newsy, and mature. BACK COVER: Nice pic; quite good, Splawn has makings of good artist; it scared me; sensational! Sincerely, E. E. Evans, Steve Hanrahan, Richard Sneary, David D. McGirr, Beak Taylor, Richard Alnutt, Harry Warner, jr., Larry Bassett, Langley Searles, R.J. Gaulin, Frank J. Davis, Gus Dallas, Ken Kruger, Walter A. Coslet, Monroe Kuttner, Dale Tarr, Lionel Inman, Norman Wegemer, Samuel D. Russell, Francis T. Laney, and Charles McNutt. . . . Thanks for writing; please come again.
Hevelin Fanzines
sidebar
